NEWS AND EVENTS
RESEARCH INSTITUTE ON SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT

The CSOs, signatories to this request strongly react to the verdict in the case against the Investigative Reporter Laboratory (IRL) for defamation that threatens freedom of association and freedom of expression. This violates some of the basic human rights guaranteed by the Constitution of the Republic of North Macedonia.

osuda

We are concerned about how the judicial authorities, with this scandalous verdict, formulated a tendentious interpretation of the Constitution and the Law on Associations and Foundations, which called into question the daily activities of more than 15,000 registered associations and foundations in fulfilling their goals. We point out that the interpretation in the judgment is completely contrary to the already established guidelines of the OSCE/ODIHR and the Venice Commission on the implementation and exercise of the right to freedom of association.

What is particularly worrisome is non-compliance with Article 20 of the Constitution, which decisively guarantees the freedom of association of citizens for the purpose of realizing and protecting their political, economic, social, cultural and other rights and beliefs. Additionally, according to Article 110, the Constitutional Court is the one that decides on the constitutionality of the programs and statutes of political parties and citizens' associations.

It is obvious that the Court, in the reasoning of the judgment, allowed itself to interpret the Law on Associations and Foundations contrary to its goals, which calls into question the freedom to perform the activities of associations and foundations. We point out that in the verdict, parts of provisions were taken that were misinterpreted, and the articles referring to the freedom of action were not taken into account. Article 14 of the AZF states that organizations can freely express and promote their views and opinions on issues of their interest, lead initiatives and participate in public opinion building and policy making. It remains unclear how the Court did not take this provision into account and whether for him the term "participating in building public opinion and creating policies" is possible without public disclosure of information about the activities of organizations within the framework of their goals.

With the placement of the verdict, the future public presentation of allegations from conducted analyses, surveys, researches and the like of any association or foundation is called into question. There is a question whether the sports clubs that are registered according to this law will be able to play a public sports match or the cultural and artistic societies will be able to hold a public concert.

We want to point out that the reference to the term organizations of public interest in the judgment is completely misused and it is obvious that the provisions of the Law on this type of association were not read to us, but only the name was used to justify the judgment. Namely, only 5 organizations of public interest have been registered in Macedonia and they have no different rights than other associations in terms of participation in building public opinion and creating policies. Organizations of public interest have powers exclusively for tax reliefs and possibly state funding, which of course is completely contrary to the interpretation in the ruling. With this, the Court allowed itself to read the Law in a completely opposite way, thus creating a negative legal practice.

It is also evident that the Court had very little knowledge of the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights (ECHR) and the position of the right to privacy versus the right to freedom of expression. The ECtHR's recommendations are that the court must balance Article 8, ie the right to privacy, with freedom of expression, Article 10, and not the other way around. The restriction of freedom of speech must be necessary in a democratic society, that is, it must be applied as a last possible measure, while it must be taken into account how seriously the restriction affects the sanctioned person, in order to avoid any censorship and discouragement of journalists and citizens to engage in criticism of the state government.

Disallowing critical thought about certain social phenomena directly conflicts with the principles of democracy and good governance. The undermining of these postulates only creates closed and trapped institutions that do not take responsibility for their negative activities. It is the associations and foundations with their work that enable the citizens to be familiar with these challenges we are facing and to work together towards the improvement of society.

The tendency of the judgment to silence the associations and foundations, which may be formed in any area, to work on the improvement of the systems in society, is more than obvious, and this is precisely why we request that the work of the particular judge be re-examined and responsibility for her be determined. work.

The associations and foundations in Macedonia remain one of the basic partners of the institutions in creating a system in which democracy, the rule of law and the fight against corruption will be the guiding principles for the future of this society.

Civil organizations and networks of civil organizations:

  • Association for Democratic Initiative (ADI)
  • Citizen Resource Center (CRC)
  • Eurotink – Center for European Strategies
  • Association for research, analysis and development ZELENA LUPA
  • Association for support of people living with HIV - TOGETHER STRONG Skopje
  • Rubicon Association
  • Institute for Democracy "Societas Civilis" Skopje
  • Institute for European Politics
  • RESIS Institute
  • Coalition All for a fair trial Connect
  • Macedonian Center for International Cooperation
  • Macedonian Association for Safety at Work
  • Macedonian Association of Young Lawyers
  • Media Plus
  • Metamorphosis Foundation for Internet and Society
  • Platform of civil society organizations to fight against corruption
  • Roma Association for Women and Youth "LULUDI"
  • Forum-Center for strategic research and documentation
  • The Union-National Council for Gender Equality supports the reaction initiative
  • Helsinki Committee for Human Rights
  • HOPS
  • FOOD FOR ALL - FOOD BANK MACEDONIA
  • Center for Civic Communications
  • Center for Research and Policy Making
  • Center for Legal Research and Analysis

SUPPORT

NGO Read More
INSTITUTIONS Read More

RESEARCH

PROJECTS Read More
PUBLICATIONS Read More